The Individual Flexibility Agreement That Cost $1.4 Million
I’ll admit my first reaction to this one was a quiet “that’s a big organisation; it’s not one of my clients”. Then I read the details, and I changed my mind.
In September 2026, Goodwin Aged Care Services, an ACT-based not-for-profit, signed an enforceable undertaking with the Fair Work Ombudsman after repaying about $1.39 million to 322 current and former employees. The organisation had reported the underpayments itself back in July 2024, so this is a story of someone doing the right thing, but slowly and at great cost.
What caused it? Individual flexibility arrangements, or IFAs. The Ombudsman found that 313 of them leaned too heavily on benefits that weren’t actually pay. Staff were being paid base rates for up to 90 ordinary hours a fortnight when the agreement capped it at 76. Some worked up to 12-hour shifts when the limit was 10, and some had only an eight-hour break between shifts instead of 10.
Most of the affected staff were migrant workers, and the Ombudsman made a point of saying that people on visas can be less aware of their rights or less comfortable speaking up. That part stayed with me.
Individual Flexibility Arrangement – Why this matters if you only have a handful of staff
Goodwin was working under an enterprise agreement, but the same principle sits inside most modern awards. If you run a cafe, a salon, a clinic, a retail shop or a small office, there is a good chance your award has a flexibility clause, and a good chance you have said yes to a request like “can I start earlier and finish earlier, and we skip the penalty rate?”
It feels kind. It often is kind. But if it isn’t done properly, it can be an underpayment waiting to surface.
The better-off overall test, in plain English
An IFA is only valid if the employee is better off overall compared with what the award would give them. That means you actually compare the two. Pay, penalty rates, hours, breaks and overtime on one side, and the arrangement on the other.
Things that aren’t pay can count. A start time that suits school drop off, or shorter days around study or health needs, are all things the Fair Work Ombudsman says you can weigh up. What the Goodwin outcome shows is that they can’t automatically make up for lost pay. The test has to be genuinely met for that person, not assumed.
Five checks before anyone signs
- Is it in writing and signed by you and the employee (and a parent or guardian if they are under 18)? Does it name exactly which award terms are being changed?
- Have you done the maths? Write down what the person would receive under the award for a typical fortnight, then what they’d receive under the IFA. If you can’t show they are better off, don’t sign.
- Was it a real choice? An IFA can’t be a condition of getting the job, and you can’t treat someone badly for saying no.
- Does the agreement explain how either of you can end it, and has the employee received a copy? You need to keep your signed copy for seven years.
- When did you last look at it? Pay rates change every July, people get promoted, and circumstances move. Put a yearly review in the diary.
The common traps I see
One template used for the whole team, even though everyone’s situation is different. A verbal “that’s fine” that never got written down. An IFA signed years ago that nobody has looked at since the last pay rise. And language barriers, where the employee said yes but didn’t really understand what they were giving up. A mock payslip or a quick walk through the numbers goes a long way here.
If you find a problem, fixing it early and telling the right people is far better than hoping it goes unnoticed. The Fair Work Ombudsman has been clear that it responds proportionately to employers who come forward and fix things.
Where we can help
If any of this made you think “I’m not sure what we agreed with Sam two years ago”, you are not alone, and it is very fixable. Our Wage & Award Sprint is a focused piece of work where we check your award coverage, pay rates, flexibility arrangements and payroll set up, so you know where you stand and what, if anything, needs tidying up.
Flexibility is good for people and for business. It just needs to be done properly, with eyes open, and with the person on the other side of the table genuinely better off.
Because fairness isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s the whole point.
Paulette

