How to dismiss an employee properly: the step-by-step process for a small business
By Paulette McCormack, CAHRI, LLB (Hons), Master of HRM, Master of Employee Relations. Founder of Fresh HR Insights (since 2012). Pillar 2: Do it properly, step by step. Updated November 2026.
A valid reason, a fair process, a show-cause step, written notice and correct final pay. Here is the seven-step process for dismissing an employee properly in a small business, updated for 2026.
To dismiss an employee properly you need a valid reason, a process that gives the person a genuine chance to respond, a final “show cause” step before you decide, written notice (or payment in lieu), correct final pay, and a record of every step. That is the whole of it. The rest of this guide is the order to do it in and the words to use.
I first wrote “How to dismiss an employee” in March 2019, and between then and 2025 Fresh HR Insights published another seven versions of the same advice under different titles. I have folded the best of all of them into this one guide. The process has barely moved in seven years. What has changed is the cost of skipping a step, and a few new ways to get it wrong.
What’s changed since we first wrote this
|
Then (March 2019) versus now (November 2026) ● The money. For dismissals from 1 July 2026 the Commission can order the lesser of 26 weeks’ pay and $95,050; the high income threshold is $190,100. Claims are at record levels: 44,075 applications of all kinds in 2024-25, 24 per cent above the five-year average. ● Final pay is now a criminal risk. Since 1 January 2025 deliberately underpaying an employee, including on the way out, is a crime, with penalties for companies of up to three times the underpayment or $8.25 million. Get the notice, leave and loadings right the first time. ● There are new rights a dismissal can collide with: the right to disconnect (small business from 26 August 2025), the casual employee choice pathway, flexible work requests with a 21-day written answer, and the right to talk about pay. Dismiss someone for using one of these and it is a general protections claim with no cap. ● A “casual” with a regular pattern may not be one. Since 26 August 2024 the real substance of the arrangement decides, so a long-term regular casual should be treated like any other employee when you end their work. ● The things that have not changed: the Form F3 is still due seven days after an application arrives, the notice table is the same, and there is still no three-warnings rule. |
Step 1: Be sure you have a valid reason
The Fair Work Act only recognises a handful of fair reasons: the person’s conduct, their capacity to do the job (performance or inability), or a genuine redundancy. Write the reason down in one or two plain sentences with dates and examples. If you cannot, you are not ready. “Bad attitude” becomes a reason only when you can describe the behaviour: the three customers who complained in May, the refusal to follow the safety direction on 12 June.
Then check the reason is not a protected one in disguise. Taking sick leave, making a complaint, asking for flexible work, being pregnant, their political opinion, refusing a late-night call: if any of these is even part of why you want them gone, stop and get advice. For a redundancy, use the redundancy guide instead; the process is different.
Step 2: Run the process before the decision
For performance, that means the person has been told clearly what is wrong, warned in writing that their job is at risk, and given a reasonable period and genuine support to improve. For misconduct, it means you have investigated: gathered the facts, shown the person the evidence and heard their explanation before forming a view. I set out the warning and improvement process, with the letters, in An effective and risk-free disciplinary process (updated 2026). Do not start this guide at Step 3 unless that work is done or the conduct is serious enough to justify summary dismissal.
Step 3: The show cause letter and meeting
This is the step most small business owners skip, and the one the Commission looks for. The show cause letter says: we are considering ending your employment for these reasons; here is what has happened so far; before we decide, we want to hear anything you want to say about why we should not. Give a date for the meeting, a few days away, and say they can bring a support person.
Prepare for the meeting the way the 2019 version of this article said and the 2021 version repeated, because it still holds:
- Choose a private room and a time that does not put the person on show in front of the team.
- Decide who will be there. You, the person, their support person if they want one, and one witness from your side to take notes. Not a wall of managers.
- Have the file in front of you: the warnings, the improvement plan, the investigation notes, the entitlements.
- Write down what you will say. Short, factual, no adjectives.
- Go in with an open mind. The Commission reads a decision made in the meeting as a decision made before it.
In the meeting, state the purpose, go through the reasons, and then stop talking. Let them respond, let them vent a little, and offer a break if they need one. Ask about anything you do not already know: a health issue, something at home, a misunderstanding. Then adjourn. Even an hour is enough to show you considered what they said.
Step 4: Decide, and weigh it up
Three questions. Is the reason valid and provable? Was the process fair (told, heard, warned, supported)? Is dismissal in proportion, and consistent with how you have treated others for the same thing? If the answer to any of them is no, the right outcome may be a final warning rather than a dismissal. If all three are yes, decide, and record the reasons.
If you have fewer than 15 employees, complete the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code checklist now, not later. For serious misconduct the Code lets you dismiss without notice if you believe, on reasonable grounds after making enquiries, that the conduct happened and justified it. For everything else it expects a warning, a reason and a chance to improve.
Step 5: The termination meeting
Keep it short and in person (or on video if the person is remote). Say the decision, the reason in a sentence, the effective date, and what happens next with pay and notice. Have the termination letter ready to hand over. Do not reopen the arguments; that was the show cause meeting. Do not say “this is hard for me too”, “it wasn’t my decision” or “you’ll find something better”. Those lines were in the 2021 version of this article and they are still the ones that come back in applications.
Treat the person with dignity on the way out. Let them collect their things, offer to post anything they leave behind, and only escort someone off the premises if there is a real risk. Cut system access at the time of the meeting, not the night before, and tell the rest of the team only that the person has left and who to go to in the meantime. Nothing more, and nothing in writing to clients about why.
Step 6: Notice, final pay and the paperwork
The minimum notice is one week for a year or less of service, two weeks for more than one and up to three years, three weeks for more than three and up to five, and four weeks for more than five, plus one extra week if the person is over 45 with at least two years’ service. Your award or contract may say more. You can let them work it or pay it out, and the payout has to include everything they would have earned in that period. Notice must be in writing. There is no notice for a casual or for serious misconduct, but every outstanding entitlement is still paid.
Final pay means wages to the last day, accrued annual leave (and loading if it applies), long service leave where the state rules say so, and notice. Not sick leave. Pay it on the last day or the next pay run, or within the time your award sets. Then issue the pay slip, update your records, and keep the file for seven years. My short guide Final pay on the last day has the detail.
Step 7: Afterwards
File everything in one place: the warnings, the show cause letter, the meeting notes, the Code checklist, the termination letter, the final pay calculation. If an application arrives you have seven days to respond, and this file is your response. See What to do when an unfair dismissal claim arrives. Then take ten minutes to ask what you would do earlier next time. Almost every dismissal I help with could have started six months sooner, with a quieter conversation.
When to call
Call me before the show cause letter goes out. That is the last point at which a dismissal can still be made safe. If someone has just stormed out, or you have just told someone to go home, call today and say nothing else to them until we have spoken.
Frequently asked questions
Can I dismiss someone on the spot?
Only for serious misconduct of the theft, violence, fraud or serious safety-breach kind, and even then you should make enquiries and hear the person first. For anything else, send them home on pay if you need to, and run the process. A sacking in anger is the most common unfair dismissal claim I see.
Do I have to give three warnings first?
No. The Act does not set a number. For performance the Commission wants to see a clear warning that the job is at risk and a genuine chance to improve. For serious misconduct no warning is needed. One good written warning beats three vague conversations.
Can I dismiss someone by email or text?
You can give notice in writing, but you should deliver the decision in a meeting. The Commission regularly criticises a termination by text or email as harsh in the way it was done, and it is one of the first things a conciliator will ask about.
Can I dismiss an employee who is on sick leave?
Being temporarily absent through illness or injury is a protected reason, so dismissing someone because they are off sick is unlawful. Dismissing them for an unrelated, proven reason while they happen to be on leave is possible but risky, and it is one to get advice on before you act.
What if they resign before I can dismiss them?
A genuine resignation ends the matter, and you then follow the resignation process instead (see Navigating employee terminations). If they resigned in the heat of the moment, give them a day to confirm it. A resignation you pushed them into is still a dismissal.
Ending someone’s employment this month?
The Termination Sprint gives you the risk assessment, the show cause and termination letters, and a word-for-word script for the meetings, with me on the phone before you walk in. If you would rather have someone on call for every people question, the monthly options are on the HR support packages page. The longer legal picture, including redundancy and insolvency, is in my guide Ending employment in Australia.
This article is general HR information. It is not legal advice. Figures are correct as at November 2026 and the Fair Work Commission updates its thresholds every 1 July.

