BACKED INTO A CORNER SERIES  |  No. 3

The Employee Who Records Everything

By Paulette McCormack, Founder and Director, Fresh HR Insights. Practical HR guidance from more than 20 years in HR, 14 of them supporting small businesses on the Gold Coast, and a Bachelor of Laws (Honours). This is general information, not legal advice. Please get advice on your own facts before you act.

The situation

Rachel runs a bakery café in Coolangatta. Fourteen staff, open seven days, and a front-of-house supervisor called Jordan, who has been with her for three years. Jordan is good with customers and knows the place inside out. Lately, he’s also been hard work.

It started with rosters. Rachel needed Jordan on Saturdays through the school holidays, and he pushed back hard. There was a one-on-one in the back office that got heated. Rachel was tired, the ovens had been down all morning, and she said something she regretted before the door had even closed behind him: “If you don’t like how I run things, there’s the door.”

Two weeks later, one of the juniors mentioned, almost as an aside, that Jordan had been “recording all his chats with Rach” on his phone. Including that one.

Rachel did what most of us would do. She said nothing and hoped it would go away. Then at the next catch-up, when she raised his lateness, Jordan put his phone on the table between them, screen down, and said: “Just so you know, I’ve got all of this recorded. And I’ll be sending it to Fair Work if I need to.”

Now Rachel feels she cannot say anything. Every conversation with Jordan is being held in a courtroom she cannot see. She has been told that recording is legal in Queensland, so she assumes she cannot do anything about it. She is worried that if she disciplines him now, it will look like payback. And underneath all of that is the thing she cannot shake: he has a recording of her losing her temper.

She feels backed into a corner. And she is not, quite. But the way out has more steps than she thinks.

Why it feels like the Act is against you (and where the balance actually sits)

Three things are true at once here, and it is the combination that makes owners feel stuck.

1. In Queensland, the recording itself is usually lawful

The Invasion of Privacy Act 1971 (Qld) makes it an offence to use a listening device to record a private conversation, but section 43 carves out a person who is a party to that conversation. Jordan was in the room. He can record it. Section 45 then restricts what he can do with the recording: publishing or communicating it is an offence unless an exception applies, and the exceptions include use in legal proceedings and communication to someone with a legitimate interest. So “I’ll send it to Fair Work” is probably within the rules. That is the part that makes owners feel powerless.

2. The Fair Work Act does not have a section about recordings

The Act doesn’t say an employee may not record you, and it doesn’t say they may. The Act does include the unfair dismissal test. Under section 385 a dismissal is unfair if it was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, and section 387 lists what the Commission weighs: whether there was a valid reason related to conduct or capacity (s 387(a)); whether the person was told the reason (s 387(b)); whether they had an opportunity to respond (s 387(c)); whether you unreasonably refused a support person (s 387(d)); the size of your business and whether you had HR expertise on hand (s 387(f) and (g)); and anything else relevant (s 387(h)).

If you have fewer than 15 employees (s 23), the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code applies through section 388. The Code lets you dismiss without notice where you believe on reasonable grounds that the conduct is serious enough to justify it. “Reasonable grounds” is doing a lot of work in that sentence. It still means you looked into it properly. And regulation 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations describes serious misconduct as wilful or deliberate behaviour that is inconsistent with the employment continuing. A secret recording can fit that description. Whether it does in your case depends on the facts.

3. The general protections sit underneath all of it

If Jordan has made a complaint, or even says he recorded Rachel because he was being treated badly, then sections 340 and 341 come into play. Dismissing him for the recording a week after a complaint looks like adverse action for exercising a workplace right, and section 361 reverses the onus: Rachel would have to prove the complaint was not part of her reason. That is why the order in which you do things matters as much as what you do.

Where the balance actually sits

Here is the part Rachel has not been told. The Fair Work Commission has been consistent for more than a decade that secretly recording workplace conversations is a breach of the duty of good faith an employee owes their employer. In Altham-Wooding (below) the Deputy President put it plainly: unless there is a justification, secret recording at work is “highly inappropriate”, and that is so whether or not it is an offence in the state where it happened. Legal under Queensland law and acceptable in the employment relationship are two different questions.

So the recording can be a valid reason for dismissal. The Commission has also said it can decline to listen to a recording made in secret, and it can take into account a recording it only learns about after the dismissal.

And yet. It is not automatic. The Commission has repeatedly noted that a secret recording will usually need “some additional element”, such as a direction not to record or a policy on recording, before it clearly justifies summary dismissal. It weighs the reason for recording, who was recorded, and whether the employer treated it as the issue at the time. It also decides for itself whether to admit a recording as evidence (section 590 lets it inform itself as it sees fit), and in some matters it has let secret recordings in, including recordings made by other workers. The safest assumption is that anything you say in that back office could be played to a Commissioner one day.

That is the real picture. The Act is not against you. It is against rushing.

What can reasonably be done?

This is the path I would walk Rachel through. Each step has a trap in it. I have named them because the traps are where the claims come from.

Step 1. Stop, and say less

Do not grab the phone, do not demand he delete anything, and do not dismiss him across the table. From this moment, assume every conversation is being recorded and speak accordingly: calm, factual, brief. If you said something you regret in an earlier meeting, own it. A short, sincere “I should not have said that, and I’m sorry” is worth more than any argument about whether the recording is admissible.

The trap: reacting. Most of the bad outcomes in this area start in the first ten minutes after the owner finds out.

 

Step 2. Work out what you actually know

A junior saying Jordan “records his chats” is a rumour. Jordan saying “I’ve got all of this recorded” is an admission, and you should write down exactly what he said, when, and who heard it, the same day. Separate what you know from what you suspect. If the only evidence is hearsay, you are not ready to allege anything.

The trap: acting on the rumour. In Stoddard, the employer’s case fell apart because it could not pin down basic facts about when and how the recording was made.

 

Step 3. Check your own paperwork

Look at the contract, the code of conduct and the handbook. Is there anything that says meetings must not be recorded without consent? Anything about confidentiality or acting in good faith? If there is nothing, you have a decision to make: rely on the general duty of good faith (which the Commission does recognise) or put a clear written direction and a short policy in place now, consult on it, and have everyone acknowledge it. The second path is slower. It is also the one that turns the next recording into a clear breach.

The trap: disciplining someone for breaking a rule you never made. The Commission has said a direction or policy is usually the “additional element” that makes a secret recording a clear valid reason.

 

Step 4. Choose the lane

There are two. Lane A is a direction and a warning: you meet, you put the concern in writing, you direct that there be no further recording without consent, and you record the outcome. Lane B is a formal misconduct process with written allegations and a show cause. Which lane depends on judgment calls: did he record a disciplinary meeting or a corridor chat; has he claimed a reason; is there a complaint on foot; did you have a policy; what is his history. Get this wrong in either direction and you are exposed. Too soft and the behaviour continues. Too hard and the Commission will ask why one recording, with no policy, ended a three-year employment.

The trap: letting the anger choose the lane.

 

Step 5. Run the process properly

Written allegations with particulars: what was recorded, when, how you know. A reasonable time to respond, which is days, not hours (in Lainas, 24 hours was “grossly inadequate”). An invitation to bring a support person. A meeting where you listen and take a note you both agree. Then a genuine pause to consider the response before you decide. Then a written outcome that explains the reason. If you are relying on the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, keep every note, because the Code asks whether you had reasonable grounds, and the notes are your grounds.

The trap: the vague letter with a short deadline. It cost the employer in Lainas more than thirty thousand dollars despite having valid reasons.

 

Step 6. Look at the whole board before you act

Before any decision, ask three questions. Has Jordan complained about anything, formally or informally, in the last few months? If the recording were played to a stranger, what would they hear from me? And am I dismissing him for the recording, or for the fact that he has a recording of me? Only the first is a valid reason. Write your answers down. Then decide, and follow through consistently.

The trap: timing. A dismissal that lands the week after a complaint carries a reverse onus under section 361, and you will be proving a negative.

Six steps. Roughly a dozen judgment calls inside them. You can do this. I would just rather you did not do it alone.

What the Commission has Actually Said

Three recent Fair Work Commission decisions. Two the employer won, sort of. One the employer lost, and the reasons why are the most useful part. Each link goes to the published decision.

Karen Altham-Wooding v PKDKAdventures Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 2753

Deputy President Saunders, Fair Work Commission. Decided 3 October 2024. Decision: https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/decisionssigned/pdf/2024fwc2753.pdf

What happened

Ms Altham-Wooding worked casually in reception and housekeeping at a holiday park on the New South Wales coast. Her hours had been cut after she told the new operators when she was not available, and she was unhappy about it. The manager texted her asking to set up a meeting. She did not reply. Instead she turned up at the park office unannounced on 28 May 2024 and, without telling anyone, recorded the whole visit on her phone.

By late July her access to the rostering app had been switched off. She sent a resignation letter a few days later, but the Commission found the employer had already ended her employment when it cut off her access. So this was a dismissal, and she brought an unfair dismissal claim. To support it, she tried to tender the secret recording.

What was decided

The Deputy President refused to let the recording in as evidence because it had been made secretly (at [42]). He then went further. Unless there is a justification, he said, “the secret recording of conversations in the workplace is highly inappropriate”, and that is so whether or not it is an offence in the state where it happened (at [43]). She had no legitimate justification here (at [45]). The recording was contrary to her duty of good faith and fidelity to her employer and undermined the trust and confidence the relationship needs (at [46]).

That gave the employer a sound, defensible and well-founded reason to dismiss her, even though the employer did not know about the recording when it made its decision (at [47] to [48]). The application failed.

On the merits, and what a small business should take from it

The employer won, and it is worth being honest about why. It was not because the process was tidy. Cutting off someone’s app access and letting them work out they have been dismissed is not a process I would ever recommend. The employer won because the employee’s own conduct handed the Commission a valid reason, and the Commission is allowed to take into account facts that only come to light after the dismissal.

What a small business should take from it: the “it’s legal in my state” argument does not protect an employee in the Commission. Secret recording is treated as a trust problem, not a criminal-law problem. But please do not read this case as “sack them and it will sort itself out”. You will not usually know the employee has recorded you until they say so, and if you dismiss on a hunch you are back in Stoddard territory (below).

Peter Lainas v AMSPEC Australia Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 311

Deputy President O’Neill, Fair Work Commission. Decided 7 February 2024. Decision: https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/decisionssigned/pdf/2024fwc311.pdf

What happened

Mr Lainas was a wharf operator who had been with the company for about twenty months when he was dismissed on 30 June 2023. The employer’s show-cause letter listed aggressive and abusive emails and comments to a payroll coordinator, his supervisor, and the safety manager, as well as vague “aggressive conduct” towards other staff. During the hearing it also came out that he had secretly recorded three conversations: a verbal warning discussion in November 2022, a mediation meeting with his manager and a colleague, and the phone call telling him he was suspended.

He was given 24 hours to respond to the show cause letter. The letter was brief, went back to things from May 2022 that had already been dealt with, and did not spell out the particulars of the most serious allegation. The company’s own witness conceded that was unfair to him.

What was decided

The Deputy President found there were valid reasons to dismiss. The covert recording of the verbal warning discussion, at least, was “highly inappropriate” and was itself a valid reason (at [56] to [60]). It did not help Mr Lainas that he told the Commission he saw nothing wrong with recording and would do it again. The aggressive communications were a valid reason too.

Yet the dismissal was still found to be harsh, unjust and unreasonable (at [81]). The allegations were “brief and unspecific”, included things already dealt with, and the employee “was given grossly inadequate time to respond” (at [70]). Reinstatement was refused because trust had gone (at [92]). Compensation of $32,587.38 was ordered, after a 30 per cent reduction for his own misconduct (at [109] and [112]).

On the merits, and what a small business should take from it

This is the case I would put in front of every owner who says “but I had a good reason”. The employer had several good reasons and still wrote a cheque for more than thirty thousand dollars, because the process fell over. Twenty-four hours to answer a vague letter that dredges up old history is not an opportunity to respond, and the Commission said so plainly.

The other lesson is quieter. The Deputy President noted the general view that a secret recording will usually need “some additional element”, such as a direction not to record or a policy about recording, before it justifies summary dismissal. That is why step three in the path below is about your own paperwork. If you have never told anyone they cannot record meetings, you are relying on the Commission to find the conduct serious enough on its own. Sometimes it will. Better not to have to hope.

Martin Stoddard v Crushing Services International Pty Ltd [2025] FWC 2673

Commissioner Simpson, Fair Work Commission. Decided 9 September 2025. Decision: https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/decisionssigned/pdf/2025fwc2673.pdf

What happened

Mr Stoddard drove trucks for a mining services contractor. On 13 May 2024 he used his phone in the workshop to show his supervisor photos of a damaged seat, and later that day he recorded workplace conversations on his Apple Watch because, in his words, he did not trust the supervisors. Months later he sent the recording to the company’s injury management adviser. The company listened to it, investigated, and dismissed him. But not for the recording. The letter relied on using a mobile phone in an operational area and on doing wheel re-torque work he was not qualified for, both of which the company only learned about from the recording itself.

What was decided

The Commissioner found neither stated reason stood up. The company thought he had recorded on his phone, not a watch, and its smartwatch notice went out two months after the recording was made (at [119] and [128]). The fitter who did the re-torque work with him was never disciplined because the company could not work out who he was (at [105]). The investigation evidence was inconsistent (at [126] to [127]).

On the recording itself: “I accept that Mr Stoddard making a secret recording of his work colleagues is a form of misconduct, but in the particular circumstances of this case, it is not misconduct sufficiently serious to warrant dismissal” (at [136]). The dismissal was unfair. Reinstatement was refused because “the covert recording of work colleagues is plainly conduct destructive of a relationship of trust and confidence” (at [152] to [153]). Compensation of $30,722.50 plus superannuation was ordered, after four weeks’ notice already paid was deducted and a further 20 per cent was taken off for the recording misconduct (at [157] and [160]).

On the merits, and what a small business should take from it

The employer lost because it built its case on what the recording revealed rather than on the recording itself, and then could not prove either allegation. Rules that arrive after the event do not count. An investigation that cannot say when things happened or who else was involved does not count either.

Notice what the Commission did and did not do. It called the secret recording misconduct, refused to put him back, and cut his money by a fifth. But it would not call one recording of colleagues, made by a worker who felt he was not being listened to, serious enough on its own to end his job. Context matters: who was recorded, why, whether there was a rule, and whether the employer treated it as the issue at the time. This is where the judgment calls live, and it is the part I would not want an owner making alone at nine o’clock at night.

What you can do as a small business owner

Today
  • Say nothing further about the recording to the employee. Write down what you know, how you know it, and the exact words used, with the date.
  • Assume you are being recorded in every conversation from now on. Keep meetings short, factual and kind.
  • If you said something in an earlier meeting you regret, plan a brief, sincere acknowledgement. Do not argue about the recording.
  • Pull out the contract, code of conduct and handbook and look for anything about recording, confidentiality or good faith.
This Week
  • Decide whether you have enough to allege anything, or whether the first move is a clear written direction and a short recording policy.
  • If there is no policy, draft one: no recording of workplace conversations or meetings without the consent of everyone present; breaches may be treated as serious misconduct. Consult, communicate, get acknowledgements.
  • Check whether the employee has raised any complaint or concern in the last few months, formal or informal. Note the dates.
  • Choose your lane (direction and warning, or formal misconduct process) and write down why.
  • Book an Ask Paulette Power Call if any of the above feels like a coin toss. It usually is one.
Before you act (checklist)
  • The allegation is in writing with particulars: what, when, how you know.
  • The employee has been given days, not hours, to respond, and was invited to bring a support person.
  • You have met, listened, and both signed or agreed a note of the meeting.
  • You have genuinely considered the response before deciding, and can show the gap in time.
  • You have checked the sequence against any complaint the employee has made (sections 340, 341 and 361).
  • Your stated reason is the conduct, not the fact that you were recorded saying something you regret.
  • If you are relying on the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, your notes show the reasonable grounds for your belief.
  • You have had someone independent read the outcome letter before it goes

Is it legal for an employee to record me without telling me in Queensland?

Usually, yes. Queensland’s Invasion of Privacy Act 1971 lets a person record a private conversation they are part of. What they can then do with it is more limited (section 45 restricts publishing or communicating it, with exceptions such as legal proceedings). Legal is not the same as acceptable, though. The Fair Work Commission has said secret recording is highly inappropriate regardless of whether it is an offence.

Can I dismiss someone for secretly recording a meeting?

It can be a valid reason, and in Altham-Wooding it was enough on its own. But it is not automatic. The Commission looks at whether there was any justification, whether you had a policy or had told them not to, and how you ran the process. In Lainas the reason was valid and the employer still paid because the process was rushed.

What if I only find out after I have already dismissed them?

The Commission can take into account facts you did not know at the time, and it did exactly that in Altham-Wooding. That is not a strategy; it is a safety net. Please do not rely on it.

Can they play the recording at Fair Work?

They can ask to. The Commission is not bound by the rules of evidence (section 590) and decides on a case-by-case basis. In Altham-Wooding, it refused because the recording was made secretly. In other matters, it has let recordings in, including recordings made by co-workers. Assume anything you say in a meeting could be played back, because it might be.

Can I record the meeting myself?

Only openly, and ideally with consent. Tell everyone at the start that the meeting is being recorded and why, note any objection, and keep the file securely. Recording someone back in secret puts you in exactly the position you are complaining about. A good written note, agreed at the end of the meeting, is often the better tool.

Do I need a policy about recording?

It is the single most useful thing you can do this week. A short clause in your code of conduct or handbook that says meetings and conversations at work are not to be recorded without the consent of everyone present, and that breaching it may be treated as serious misconduct. The Commission has said a direction or policy is usually the “additional element” that turns a secret recording into a clear valid reason.

What if they say they recorded me because they were being bullied?

Take the claim seriously and deal with it as a complaint, separately from the recording issue. If there is a genuine complaint on foot, dismissing them for the recording a week later will look like adverse action (sections 340 and 341), and under section 361 you would have to prove it was not. Sequence and documentation matter enormously here.

Should I tell them to delete it?

No. You cannot force them to, you may be asked to explain the demand later, and if it becomes relevant to a claim you have just asked them to destroy evidence. Put your energy into the process instead.

Have a question that hasn't been answered?

Because in the end, it is your business. It should feel like it.

With Fresh HR Insights, You Get Expert HR Help, Exactly When You Need It

Most owners who ring me about a recording are not really ringing about the recording. They are ringing because they have lost the ability to speak freely in their own business, and they want it back. Here is how I usually help. Practical, expert HR support to help you manage your people confidently, resolve workplace issues and stay compliant. Explore our packages below to find the right level of support for your business.

Ask Paulette: A 20-Min HR Power Call

Learn More

HR Health Check: 60-Min Mini-Audit + Risk Snapshot

Learn More

Starter HR Support for Micro-Businesses

Learn More

Ad-Hoc HR Support

Learn More

Small Business HR Support

Learn More

Wage & Award Sprint

Learn More

Termination Sprint

Learn More

Redundancy Sprint: Templates + Expert Walk-Through

Learn More

Premium HR – Strategic HR for Growing Teams

Learn More

FREE One-page fact sheet

GoHighLevelAgency Arcade, About Us - Agency Arcade, Contact Us - Agency Arcade, Our Services - Agency Arcade